Gunn’s DCU Built the Wrong Things First
James Gunn is out as head of DC Studios after the Skydance–Warner Bros. merger. Even his Superman underdelivered, and his universe never came together — and his successor should hit the reset button.
James Gunn’s run as the architect of the DC Universe is over. Skydance announced Monday that Gunn and co-CEO Peter Safran will step down Dec. 1, about a month after Paramount Skydance closed its $111 billion acquisition of Warner Bros. Discovery. Former Marvel Studios producer Jeremy Latcham, whose credits include “The Avengers” and “Spider-Man: Homecoming,” takes over as president and chief creative officer.
Gunn isn’t leaving entirely. He’ll still produce, and his “Superman” sequel, “Man of Tomorrow,” is still set for July 9, 2027. But the keys to the universe are changing hands, and it’s fair to ask why a regime that arrived with so much optimism is leaving after four years with so little built.
The reporting since then paints a harsher picture. According to The Hollywood Reporter, the split came down to structure. Gunn and Safran had reported directly to Skydance CEO David Ellison, were used to having the final word and balked at being placed beneath the studio’s film chiefs. Sources also said the pair were slow to share slate plans and footage with the new regime.
The results didn’t buy them any leeway. Supergirl was viewed as a box office disaster, and even Superman reportedly didn’t impress Skydance enough, at the box office or in pop culture. Ellison reportedly wants the Justice League on screen as soon as possible, and one producer told TheWrap that audiences didn’t want Gunn’s “cornball” approach.
The timing may have been about the next movie, too. Cosmic Book News, citing unnamed insiders, reported that Skydance moved now, instead of letting Gunn’s contract run out in April 2027, to lock him out of post-production on “Man of Tomorrow,” a cut the studio reportedly isn’t excited about. The major trades haven’t confirmed that, and Skydance hasn’t commented.
My answer goes beyond taste. Gunn spent his early picks on the wrong characters, and the numbers never justified the patience.
The optimism was real
When Warner Bros. handed DC to Gunn in 2022, it felt like the right call. He’d made The Suicide Squad and Peacemaker work, and he’d turned a talking raccoon and a tree into household names at Marvel. If anyone could make a shared DC universe click, it seemed like him.
Superman was the high point, and David Corenswet was a terrific Clark Kent. But look at the numbers objectively, and even the win looks thin.
Superman wasn’t enough
“Superman” grossed about $618 million worldwide on a $225 million production budget, plus roughly $100 million in marketing. It turned a profit, reportedly more than $100 million. For the flagship launch of a new universe, that’s a passing grade, not a triumph.
Compare it to Marvel, because Marvel is DC’s direct competition whether DC likes it or not. Ant-Man and the Wasp, a 2018 sequel built on Marvel’s B-tier lineup, earned about $623 million worldwide on a $130 million budget. Marvel’s second-string sequel outgrossed DC’s most famous hero seven years earlier, at well under two-thirds of the cost.
That should have set off alarms. Instead, the follow-ups got smaller.
Supergirl and Clayface were not the next pulls
If you’re building a universe from scratch, your first handful of releases are the most valuable real estate you’ll ever have. Gunn used two of his first three theatrical films on Supergirl and Clayface.
Supergirl was the costly mistake. Milly Alcock earned praise, but the film landed in the high 50s on Rotten Tomatoes, opened to about $37 million domestically and finished around $126 million worldwide against a reported $170 million budget. It was the first DCU film with real critical pushback, and it opened below The Marvels.
Clayface deserves fairer treatment. Made for roughly $44 million, the R-rated body-horror film opened No. 1 and drew solid reviews. As a midbudget experiment, it worked. But that’s the point: it’s the kind of swing you take in year five, after audiences already care about your Batman. Releasing a film about a Batman villain before your universe even has a Batman is backward.
And the offbeat instinct never went away. Just two weeks ago, Gunn said a prequel series about Polka-Dot Man’s family had been discussed, though it isn’t in active development. Polka-Dot Man is a character Gunn himself once described finding by Googling the dumbest supervillain of all time. That’s a fun detail for a Suicide Squad movie. It’s not where your head should be when the Justice League doesn’t exist yet.
There’s a pattern here. Gunn gravitates toward the strange, the overlooked and the cosmic, the formula that worked for “Guardians of the Galaxy.” “Supergirl” even drew comparisons to that franchise. What the DCU needed in its first wave was more grounded material built around the characters general audiences already know.
Where was Batman?
The most glaring hole is the biggest name in the catalog. Outside Matt Reeves’ separate Batman universe with Robert Pattinson, a film that predates Gunn’s arrival, there is no Batman in the DCU. The Brave and the Bold was announced in January 2023 and, according to The Wall Street Journal, was hoped for a 2028 release. That’s six years into the regime before DC’s most bankable hero would show up. The Batman Part II is set for February 2028, still on its own island.
The Journal also reported that Gunn’s plan was for his Superman sequels in 2029 and 2031 to gradually grow into Justice League films. So the league was on the board. It was just always five years away.
Latcham’s first job: find Batman
Peter Safran is out alongside Gunn, so the next move belongs to Latcham. His first priority should be obvious: establish the DCU’s Batman.
Batman is the most valuable property DC owns. Gunn sat on him for four years, and it’s hard not to see why. Batman is a grounded, street-level hero, and Gunn’s instincts always pulled toward the cosmic and the supernatural. But Batman is too iconic and too central to this universe to keep waiting on. Every year without him is a year the DCU feels incomplete.
That means finding a Batman who belongs to this universe, not borrowing one from another.
Stop splitting the audience
Robert Pattinson was very good in The Batman, and The Penguin was a great series. But Matt Reeves’ Gotham lives in its own universe, and that’s part of the problem.
If it were up to me, The Batman Part II would have been shelved years ago. It’s been stuck in development since 2022 and is now set for February 2028. With cameras already rolling, scrapping it isn’t realistic. Folding Pattinson into the DCU is the other option, and while I don’t love it, I’m not opposed to it either.
Skydance may be headed that way anyway. Puck reports The Batman Part II could end Reeves’ universe, with Ellison wanting DC’s most profitable character back in the main continuity. That’s the right call.
What DC can’t keep doing is releasing movies and shows about its own characters that don’t count. Two Batmen in two universes, with a third in development, is confusing for anyone who isn’t tracking every press release. Whatever Latcham decides about Reeves, the next Batman project should be DCU canon, full stop.
The case for another reset
Latcham’s biggest call is whether to build on Gunn’s foundation or start over. Skydance may already be leaning my way. Puck’s Matthew Belloni reports that plans are afoot to dismantle much of Gunn’s slate, with only Man of Tomorrow, The Batman Part II and one HBO series (that is not season two of Lanterns) considered safe. If that’s true, good. Start over.
It’s the riskier, more expensive call in the short run, and fans are tired of DC starting from scratch. But the DCU is still young, and its results don’t justify protecting it. Its biggest win trailed a Marvel B-team sequel. Its second film bombed. Its third worked, but on a $44 million scale that can’t carry a universe. Its strongest pieces, Peacemaker and Lanterns, live on HBO.
Here’s how I’d do it. Let the rest of Gunn’s produced material, including Man of Tomorrow in July 2027, come out as scheduled. Then take a year off. Use that time to lay out the whole universe, the lineup, the order and the endgame, before a camera rolls. Then relaunch with one vision carried through every film and show.
Contracts may not even stand in the way. Cosmic Book News, citing Skydance insiders, reports that Corenswet’s DC contract has been fulfilled and he’s done as Superman after Man of Tomorrow. If that holds, the biggest obstacle to a reset is already gone, and recasting Superman is a choice, not a buyout. Starting over still costs money. But so does sinking another five years into a foundation that’s already cracked.
Start grounded
DC has a problem Marvel never had. Marvel’s heroes mostly live in New York and other real places audiences recognize. DC’s live in fictional cities like Gotham, Metropolis and Central City, and many live somewhere surreal: deep space, Atlantis, Themyscira. That’s a harder sell to a casual audience on day one.
So start on the ground, with the two most grounded members of the Justice League.
- Batman. The new universe’s own Batman, with a new actor. First in line, nonnegotiable.
- The Flash. The Flash bombed in 2023 under a cloud of controversy surrounding Ezra Miller, and most audiences never connected with it. That makes it an easy chance to start fresh, and Barry Allen’s street-level, science-based origin keeps the new universe grounded.
Once audiences buy into that world, bring in Superman and Wonder Woman. Then go cosmic with characters like Martian Manhunter, whom no DC film universe has really used, and Green Lantern, who deserves a film that erases the memory of 2011. Introduce each one before they share the screen, then assemble the league.
Save Darkseid
One more lesson from Marvel: don’t rush your biggest villain. Marvel teased Thanos at the end of The Avengers in 2012 and didn’t pay him off until 2018. That patience is why Avengers: Infinity War landed.
DC should treat Darkseid the same way. Give the first Justice League film a more contained threat and tease Darkseid as the endgame for the next decade.
Let Gunn be Gunn
None of this makes Gunn a bad filmmaker. The lesson is that he’s great in his lane. Give him a quirky, offbeat comic book property and he’ll make stars out of characters nobody knew, the way he did with Guardians of the Galaxy and Peacemaker. What he struggled to do was build and run an entire universe.
I’d take him back at Marvel in a heartbeat for Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 4. He has always called Vol. 3 the end of his trilogy and once declared himself “pure DC.” That’s no longer the case, and there are plenty of Guardians stories left to tell.
Whatever Latcham decides, the lesson of the Gunn era is simple: a shared universe is built on the characters people already love. Get them on screen, get them together and save the deep cuts for later.
